Five Guys Milkshake Menu & Mix-Ins (Prices)

The latest Five Guys milkshake menu 2026 has 10 regular mix-ins: Coffee, Banana, Strawberry, Oreo® Cookies, Peanut Butter, Bacon, Oreo® Crème, Salted Caramel, REESE’S Cups, and Chocolate. Seasonal flavors also appear from time to time, so the available choices can expand during special promotions. If you want to know available flavors, calorie counts, ingredients, allergens, seasonal options, and popular combinations before you order, we cover each section in detail below.

Five Guys Milkshake Menu Prices 2026

In 2026, a regular Five Guys milkshake typically costs between $6.00 and $8.00 in the United States. Standard restaurant prices usually sit near $6.00 to $7.00, but branches in cities such as New York or Seattle may charge above $8.00.

Order Type /	Milkshake Price	Calories	What Is Included
Standard Five Guys Location	6.00–7.00	670 cal before mix-ins	One vanilla milkshake base with your choice of regular mix-ins.
High-Cost Location	8.00–8.39+	670 cal before mix-ins	The same standard shake and mix-in options, but local menu prices may be higher.
Other Delivery Apps	Around $8.39+	670 cal before mix-ins	One milkshake with available mix-ins; service, delivery, and other app fees cost extra.
Average Price Range	6.00–8.39+	670+ cal	The final price and calorie total depend on the restaurant, order method, and selected mix-ins. //

Five Guys Milkshakes Mix-Ins Menu

Five Guys restaurant takes a different approach to milkshakes. Instead of several fixed flavors, customers can customize their shakes with different mix-ins. Every shake starts with a Handspun vanilla milkshake with free mix-ins like bacon, strawberries, and Oreo. Build your favorite combo and top it with whipped cream.

Five Guys Mix-In	Added Calories, Standard Portion	Extra Cost	Total Price After Mix-In
Coffee	5 cal	Free ($0)	$6.69 – $7.19
Strawberry	20 cal	Free ($0)	$6.69 – $7.19
Banana	30 cal	Free ($0)	$6.69 – $7.19
Chocolate	40 cal	Free ($0)	$6.69 – $7.19
Salted Caramel	45 cal	Free ($0)	$6.69 – $7.19
Oreo® Cookies	65 cal	Free ($0)	$6.69 – $7.19
Bacon	80 cal	Free ($0)	$6.69 – $7.19
Oreo® Crème	90 cal	Free ($0)	$6.69 – $7.19
Peanut Butter	90 cal	Free ($0)	$6.69 – $7.19
REESE’S® Cups	150 cal	Free ($0)	$6.69 – $7.19

Approximate totals combine the 670-calorie vanilla base with one mix-in. Two or more mix-ins can produce a different final nutrition value because portion amounts may vary.

Popular Five Guys Milkshake Combos

Some flavor combinations work better than others, and Five Guys highlights several pairings on its own menu. You can pair a shake with a burger from the Five Guys burgers menu or with fries from the Five Guys fries menu for a full meal.

Combination	Mix-Ins	Flavor Style
Coffee Mocha	Coffee + Chocolate	Deep and bitter
Peanut Butter Banana	Peanut Butter + Banana	Sweet and nutty
Strawberry Banana	Strawberry + Banana	Fruity and smooth
Strawberry Oreo	Strawberry + Oreo® Cookies + Oreo® Crème	Fruity and cookie-rich
Peanut Butter Banana Bacon	Peanut Butter + Banana + Bacon	Sweet, nutty, and salty
Chocolate REESE’S®	Chocolate + REESE’S® Cups	Rich chocolate and peanut butter
Bacon Salted Caramel	Bacon + Salted Caramel	Sweet and salty
Oreo® Peanut Butter	Oreo® Cookies + Peanut Butter	Rich and crunchy

Five Guys Milkshake Flavors

Coffee

Coffee gives the vanilla shake a stronger, slightly bitter contrast without adding a large number of calories. The mix-in contributes 27 calories, which makes it the lightest regular option on the current menu. A vanilla shake with Coffee comes to about 697 calories. Coffee also works well with Chocolate or Salted Caramel if you prefer a richer flavor.

Banana

Banana adds a sweeter fruit taste and contributes 174 calories. A shake with Banana alone comes to about 844 calories. You can pair Banana with Peanut Butter for a richer combination. Bacon also gives the fruit flavor a salty contrast if you prefer something less conventional.

Strawberry

Strawberry adds 107 calories and gives the vanilla base a lighter fruit flavor. A Strawberry shake comes to about 777 calories before another mix-in. Oreo Cookies can give Strawberry more texture and a dessert-style taste. Banana also works well if you want a fruit-focused combination.

Oreo® Cookies

Oreo Cookies contribute 120 calories. A vanilla shake with the cookie mix-in comes to about 790 calories. You can pair Oreo Cookies with Strawberry, Chocolate, or Oreo Crème. Five Guys also features Oreo as part of one of its own suggested combinations.

Peanut Butter

Peanut Butter has the highest calorie value among the current regular mix-ins at 322 calories. A vanilla shake with Peanut Butter comes to about 992 calories. The flavor works especially well with Banana, Chocolate, or REESE’S Cups. If you want a lighter shake, Coffee, Bacon, or Strawberry adds far fewer calories.

Bacon

Bacon may sound unusual in a milkshake, but Five Guys uses it as a sweet-and-salty option. The mix-in adds 70 calories, so a Bacon shake comes to about 740 calories. Salted Caramel pairs especially well with Bacon. Five Guys features the combination on its own shake menu.

Oreo® Crème

Oreo Crème adds the sweet cream portion of an Oreo and contributes 320 calories. A vanilla shake with Oreo Crème comes to about 990 calories. You can combine it with Oreo Cookies for a fuller cookie flavor. Strawberry also adds a fruit note that balances the sweetness.

Salted Caramel

Salted Caramel contributes 155 calories and adds a sweet flavor with a salty edge. A shake with Salted Caramel comes to about 825 calories. Coffee gives the caramel a stronger contrast. Bacon creates another sweet-and-salty combination.

REESE’S Cups

REESE’S Cups contribute 150 calories and combine chocolate with peanut butter in one mix-in. A shake with REESE’S Cups comes to about 820 calories. Chocolate is the obvious partner if you want a richer dessert flavor. Peanut Butter can push the nutty taste even further.

Chocolate

Chocolate adds 133 calories to the vanilla base. A simple Chocolate shake comes to about 803 calories. Coffee, REESE’S Cups, Peanut Butter, and Salted Caramel all pair naturally with Chocolate. You can also choose Chocolate alone if you prefer a more familiar shake flavor.

Seasonal Five Guys Milkshake Flavors

Five Guys occasionally adds a limited-time flavor alongside its regular mix-ins. Seasonal options do not stay on the permanent menu, so availability depends on the time of year and restaurant. Blackberry appeared in summer 2026 as a limited-time mix-in. Five Guys used Oregon-grown Marion blackberries plus other blackberry varieties, and the flavor remained available through the middle of August. Candy Cane Crunch also appeared as a holiday option from November 10, 2025, through January 5, 2026. The flavor added peppermint and candy cane pieces to the vanilla base. Neither Blackberry nor Candy Cane Crunch belongs to the current permanent U.S. menu. A local Five Guys branch may introduce another seasonal option in the future.

Does Five Guys Have 10 or 11 Milkshake Mix-Ins?

The updated Five Guys menu has 10 regular mix-ins. Some menu guides mention 11 because seasonal flavors can temporarily expand the selection. Blackberry raised the choice during summer 2026, and Candy Cane Crunch filled a similar role during the previous holiday period. You should treat 10 as the current permanent count. An 11th option only applies if Five Guys has an active seasonal flavor at the time of your order.

Five Guys Milkshake Ingredients

Every standard shake starts with a vanilla base. The base contains dairy ingredients, sugar, whey, stabilizers, and flavor components. The final ingredient list depends on your mix-ins. Chocolate adds cocoa-based ingredients, Oreo Cookies introduce cookie pieces, Peanut Butter adds peanuts, and REESE’S Cups add chocolate and peanut-based ingredients. Whipped cream also has its own ingredient profile and adds another dairy component. If you have an allergy or food intolerance, you should review the latest Five Guys allergen information before you order because ingredient formulas can change.

Can You Customize a Five Guys Milkshake?

Yes. Customization is one of the main reasons the Five Guys shake menu offers so much variety. You can choose a single mix-in for a simple flavor, or you can combine several options in one shake. Regular mix-ins carry no separate add-on charge under the standard menu policy, so a custom shake costs the same base price as a plain shake at the same restaurant. A combination such as Chocolate and REESE’S® Cups gives you a familiar chocolate and peanut butter taste. Strawberry with Oreo® Cookies gives you a fruit and cookie mix, and Bacon with Salted Caramel offers a sweet and salty option.

• You can select a single mix-in and enjoy a clean and direct flavor.
• Combine two or three mix-ins and create a balanced custom shake
• You can request no whipped cream and save 20 calories from the total.
• Staff can add extra portions of a favorite mix-in, and extra portions raise the calorie total fast.

What Makes Five Guys Milkshakes Different?

• The menu does not treat every flavor as a separate pre-set shake. Five Guys uses one vanilla base and lets you create your own flavor through mix-ins.
• Free regular mix-ins also give you more flexibility. You can choose one flavor or combine several without a separate charge for each regular mix-in.
• Seasonal flavors add another reason to check the menu from time to time. Blackberry appeared during summer 2026, and Candy Cane Crunch had a holiday run before that.
• The system suits customers who want more control over taste. You can choose a lighter Coffee shake, a fruit option such as Strawberry, or a richer mix with Peanut Butter, Oreo Crème, and Chocolate.

Five Guys Milkshake Calories and Nutrition

grams of saturated fat, 84 grams of carbohydrates, 82 grams of sugar, 13 grams of protein, and 360 milligrams of sodium. Mix-ins change the calorie total at very different rates. Coffee adds only 5 calories for a standard portion, and REESE’S® Cups add 150 calories under the same system. Whipped cream adds another 20 calories, so a shake with several mix-ins can move well above the plain vanilla total.

Item	Calories	Fat	Saturated Fat	Carbs	Sugar	Protein	Sodium
Vanilla Shake Base, 396g	670	32g	21g	84g	82g	13g	360mg
Whipped Cream	20	1.5g	1g	1g	1g	0g	0mg

Lowest-Calorie Five Guys Milkshake

The plain vanilla shake has the lowest standard total at 670 calories. Coffee has the lowest regular mix-in value at 5 calories for a standard portion, so a vanilla Coffee shake totals about 675 calories. can also choose Strawberry at 690 calories or Banana at 700 calories for a light flavored shake. If calorie count matters to you, one lower-calorie mix-in gives you a simpler choice than a shake with Peanut Butter, REESE’S® and Oreo Crème.

Are Five Guys Milkshakes Gluten-Free?

The vanilla shake base does not list wheat as an ingredient, but your choice of mix-in can change the answer. Oreo Cookie Pieces contain wheat, and REESE’S Cup ingredient information notes possible wheat exposure. Other mix-ins have separate allergen profiles. Cross-contact can also occur inside a restaurant. A customer with coeliac disease or a serious gluten allergy should check the latest official allergen guide and speak with restaurant staff before placing an order. Your mix-ins and your personal level of sensitivity matter in each case, and a direct check gives you the safest answer.

Five Guys Milkshake Allergens

Milk is the main allergen in the vanilla shake base. Other allergens depend on the flavors you choose. Peanut Butter contains peanuts. Oreo Cookies contain wheat and soy, and REESE’S Cups contain milk, peanuts, and soy, with possible exposure to other allergens. Restaurant preparation can also create cross-contact. Anyone with a serious food allergy should use the current Five Guys allergen guide rather than rely only on a general menu article.

What Size Is a Five Guys Milkshake?

Five Guys keeps the shake menu simple rather than offering several size tiers. The official nutrition information lists one standard vanilla shake base at 396 grams. Flavor choice creates more variation than size choice on the menu. Your final calorie total depends mainly on the number and the type of mix-ins in your cup, and whipped cream adds 20 calories on top of the base total.

Are Five Guys Milkshake Mix-Ins Free?

Yes. Regular milkshake mix-ins do not have a separate charge under the standard Five Guys shake policy. You can add more than one regular flavor if you want a custom combination. The price of the base shake can still vary by restaurant, so the total you see at one branch may differ from another location.

Final Thoughts on the Five Guys Milkshake Menu

Five Guys gives you more flexibility than a basic list of fixed shake flavors. The current menu has 10 regular mix-ins, and each one changes the taste and calorie total in a different way.

Coffee offers the lightest regular add-on at 27 calories, whereas Peanut Butter adds 322 calories. Fruit choices such as Banana and Strawberry sit between the two ends, and richer options such as Oreo Crème, Chocolate, and REESE’S Cups suit customers who prefer a more dessert-like shake.

Seasonal flavors can expand the Five Guys milkshake menu 2026 during the year, but the permanent lineup remains the best reference if you plan a visit now. Milkshake menu Prices also vary by restaurant, so the official Five Guys locator or local order page gives you the most accurate cost for your nearest branch.

Five Guys Milkshake Menu FAQs